Former Vice President Joe Biden, Senator Elizabeth Warren and Senator Bernie Sanders – the frontrunners for the 2020 Democratic nomination – clashed over the best way to expand healthcare coverage for Americans during Thursday’s debate.
The divide among the candidates over the proposal known as Medicare for All, which would cover every American under a government health plan and essentially eliminate private insurance, was again laid bare in the opening moments of the Democratic Party’s third presidential debate in Houston.
But after some sharp exchanges, several of the White House contenders warned that too much acrimony would distract them from the ultimate goal: defeating Republican President Donald Trump next year.
Here are some early highlights from the debate:
‘The damn bill’
The first question of the night went to Biden, asking him whether liberals like Warren and Sanders had gone too far left for mainstream Democrats.
Biden quickly pivoted to healthcare, challenging Sanders of Vermont and Warren of Massachusetts to explain how they plan to pay for what some analysts expect would be a $30 trillion Medicare for All plan.
There’s enormous opportunity once we get rid of Donald Trump. #DemDebate
“Thus far, my distinguished friend, the senator on my left, has not said how she’s going to pay for it,” said Biden, referring to Warren.
Both Warren and Sanders were careful to avoid saying explicitly that middle-class families would see higher taxes, instead emphasizing that they would save money overall by eliminating medical costs.
“Those at the very top, the richest and corporations, are going to pay more,” Warren said. “Middle-class families are going to pay less.”
My story has a lot of twists and turns, but I was resilient. I kept fighting, and I lived my dream. I’m standing here today because I got back up, and I fought back. I know what’s broken, and I want to be in the fight to fix it. #DemDebate
Sanders acknowledged the cost of his signature plan – but said studies show the status quo will cost Americans $50 trillion over the same time period.
“I wrote the damn bill, if I may say so,” he said, repeating his main applause line from the second debate in July.
Biden emphasised again that his plan would allow people who like their private insurance to keep it, a key point of distinction from Sanders’ and Warren’s approach.
“Let’s be clear – I’ve actually never met anybody who likes their health insurance company,” Warren replied. “I’ve met people who like their doctors.”
I know what it’s like to grow up in a family that lives paycheck to paycheck. That is something I will never forget. #DemDebate
When Sanders noted Americans spend far more per capita on healthcare than Canadians, Biden interrupted, saying, “This is America.”
“Americans don’t want to pay twice as much as other countries,” Sanders shot back.
Medicare for all: A bold idea or a bad idea?
Other candidates seeking to make their mark on the stage also took aim at Sanders’ Medicare for All plan.
U.S. Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, who has run as a moderate, said Sanders’ proposal would force millions of people off their insurance plans.
“While he wrote the bill, I read the bill,” she said. “I don’t think that’s a bold idea, I think that’s a bad idea.”
South Bend, Indiana, Mayor Pete Buttigieg sought to contrast his proposal to offer a government plan as an alternative, which he describes as “Medicare for all who want it,” with Sanders’ more sweeping reform.
“The problem is that it doesn’t trust the American people,” he said of the senator’s plan. “I trust you to choose what makes the most sense for you.”
I know how important having a teacher who looks like you is to your success. #DemDebate
U.S. Senator Kamala Harris of California, who has released her own Medicare for All plan, redirected the conversation toward Trump, noting that the current administration has sought to strike down the entire Affordable Care Act, commonly known as Obamacare, in federal court.
“I think this discussion has given the American people a headache,” she said. “What they want to know is that they’re going to have healthcare and the cost.”
‘A house divided’
Although the candidates had a heated discussion about healthcare in the first 40 minutes of the debate, several stressed the importance of standing together as Democrats, saying fighting one another would play into Trump’s hands.
Moments after former U.S. Housing Secretary Julian Castro, 44, of Texas accused Biden, 76, of forgetting what he had just said two minutes ago – a comment seemingly aimed at Biden’s age that many in the audience jeered – Buttigieg called for civility.
“This is why presidential debates are becoming unwatchable,” Buttigieg said. “This reminds everybody of what they cannot stand about Washington. Scoring points against each other, poking at each other.”
Trust can be reciprocated. Part of winning is knowing what’s worth more to you than winning—and that’s what we need in the presidency right now. #DemDebate
Castro was unbowed. “That’s called a Democratic primary election. That’s called an election. This is what we’re here for, it’s an election.”
“Yeah, but a house divided cannot stand,” said Klobuchar, quoting former President Abraham Lincoln.
That sentiment was echoed by U.S. Senator Cory Booker of New Jersey, who said while they had differences on how to pay for and deliver healthcare, every person on stage believed in universal care.
“We cannot sacrifice progress on the altar of purity,” he said.